I hope you all don't mind a bit of a catch up post! These past two weeks of summer reading have been delightful—in addition to these vintage reads, I dove into a new early reader, a recently-released adult historical fiction and a soon-to-be-released adult historical fiction, all of which I plan on sharing with you soon. I haven't done too much besides read, as after the non-stop pace of play rehearsals and long daily drives for the musical my children were in, my body decided to force me to give it a rest. Luckily sick days are good reading days! For week three of the Vintage Kidlit Summer reading challenge I'm hosting with Anna Rose Johnson, the theme was Magical Adventures. We actually both chose to read Half Magic, by Edward Eager. As one commenter on Instagram pointed out, this book is a book-lover's dream, as old favorite stories are woven into the plot and environment of the story. After just a few pages, I was ready to dive into E. Nesbit again—and maybe I will, later this summer! For week four, I re-read Emily's Runaway Imagination, which I now think may be Beverly Cleary's most underrated book. I love the episodic style and historical setting (she wrote it as historical fiction, unlike her Henry/Beezus/Ramona stories). I love the little vignette scenes as well as the drama of the biggest plot point: can Emily and her mother bring a library to small-town Oregon?
What surprised me most, not having read this since I was about ten, was one very important and understated theme in this story: racism. Not exactly what you'd expect from a Beverly Cleary novel, right? And yet I found that Emily's experiences relating to her elderly Chinese neighbor had a ring of authenticity and courage. At the beginning of the story, Emily is afraid to take the road that goes by Fong Quock's house—not, as you might expect, because she is afraid of the Chinese man, but because she is afraid of herself. She has a hard time understanding his accent, as he is the only Chinese person she has ever met, and she is afraid she will hurt his feelings if she misunderstands. She's also honestly afraid of embarrassing herself because of her misunderstanding, which I also find very relatable—how often are our intentions totally pure? Throughout the story, Emily always speaks of Fong Quock with respect and admiration, but her fears almost make her miss out entirely on the chance to connect with him in a genuine way. Now, like many vintage books, Emily falls into a few stereotypical depictions of Chinese that I'm sure modern readers may justifiably object to. In these cases, I like to take Mitali Perkin's advice and read more widely, to get a more full and nuanced view of any pinpointed time and place. Certainly Emily's experiences with her Chinese neighbor seem honest and good-hearted…but what would the point of view of a Chinese immigrant in 1920's Oregon look like? How would his version of the story look different? Maybe you all can help me out there. Do you readers have any good recommendations for stories of Chinese immigrants to the Northeast U.S. in the 20's? This week, we're moving on to A Book in a Series—which pretty much encompasses about 80% of my favorite vintage books, so I'm having a hard time choosing. Any must-read series on your lists of favorites?
11 Comments
6/26/2023 09:39:09 am
I love the Cynthia Voight series. My only disappointment was that I didn't discover Dicey and her family until I was an adult. That's the problem of starting adult books early; I skipped over from Nancy Drew to Perry Mason.
Reply
Valinora Troy
6/26/2023 10:01:25 am
I've added Half-Magic to my TBR (I had never heard of it before). Hope you are fully recovered!! :)
Reply
6/26/2023 11:59:41 am
I don't think I have ever read this book by Beverly Cleary! I read every book of hers that we had in our school and town library- but they must not have had it on the shelves. Sounds interesting! I also don't think I have read Half Magic. Love that you are reading some vintage books and going down memory lane. :)
Reply
6/26/2023 12:45:46 pm
Thanks for sharing this vintage book! I had never heard of it before. This isn't quite the right time period/location, but I recently read PAPER DAUGHTERS OF CHINATOWN by Heather B. Moore and Allison Hong Merrill. It's set in California in the 1890s, but gives the perspective of Chinese immigrants, specifically young girls.
Reply
Max @ Completely Full Bookshelf
6/26/2023 02:57:27 pm
I really appreciate these reviews, Faith! I remember really enjoying Half Magic a long time ago, so it's fun to see that story making the rounds. And it's interesting to hear about the Beverly Cleary book, with the two sides of some dated elements but also a forward-thinking look at racism too. I'm not a big reader of historical fiction, but I know one book I've heard a lot about that gives an alternate perspective is Prairie Lotus by Linda Sue Park (the protagonist is half-Chinese in an American small town in the 1880s). Thanks so much for sharing your thoughts!
Reply
6/27/2023 11:04:46 am
These two stories sound perfect for a summertime read. I thought I'd read every Beverly Clearly book but somehow missed this one. Thanks for featuring your review on MMGM this week. Looking forward to your next reviews whether they are MG or adult.,
Reply
Marion
6/27/2023 04:21:54 pm
Hi Elizabeth;
Reply
6/27/2023 07:51:28 pm
I haven't read either of these, but I will certainly be looking for Emily's Runaway Imagination. It sounds like a terrific book. Thanks for the reviews.
Reply
6/28/2023 09:34:29 am
Faith, Half Magic sounds so delightful. I discovered Beverly Clearly as a grown up, with my kids. But if you're looking for an interesting book from an Asian perspective that's set in the Pacific NW, look no farther than Jamie Ford's Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet. It's not the time-frame you're looking for. This revolves around the Japanese internment in the US during WWII. I won't forget Henry, the Chinese kid, whose father makes him wear a button saying he's Chinese so that he wouldn't be taken for Japanese.
Reply
Marilyn
6/28/2023 11:36:02 am
Hi Elizabeth Hope you are feeling better. Have you read Cheaper By The Dozen and the sequel Bells On Their Toes. by Frank Bunker Gilbreth Jr.? Another series is The Story Girl by Lucy Maud Montgomery. The Moffets are another great series by Elleanor Estes. Looking forward to your future post concerning historical novels, one of my favorite read,
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
About meHi! I'm Faith. I blog about books and creativity, family and faith. Welcome! Archives
September 2024
Categories
All
|